shopping for H&M stationary easy chair and ottoman

Looking to replace husbands leather chair and ottoman. Hubby is 5'10" 180lbs. Current chair inside seat depth 21" and 24" wide. Seat height 17" arm height 24". We get transferred often so we prefer furniture that is smaller in scale, 36" deep vs 44" deep. Our style is craftsman/mission. Any personal favorites or feedback would be helpful. Considering the following chairs with ottomans;
Member, Evening, Charter, City, Garden, Anderson, Ashmore

thank you for your assistance
grace