Unfinished leathers that feel soft & buttery?

Of the following unfinished leathers, which do you think would would have the softest feel in a range of 1-10? "1" is like buttah... "10" is shiny, crunchy & crispy. I don't want to ask Duane for samples of many leathers that I might not like. Capri is probably a given first... but after that?

• Atticus chestnut
• Capri butternut
• Hand antiqued saddle
• Mesquite saddle lightly burnished
• Rio whiskey
• Stampede harness
• Sonoma chestnut
• Scout clove
• Tiburon chestnut
• Tuscany saddle
• Weston tobacco
• Yardley tobacco

thanks! Really enjoying this forum and learning a lot.

Just on Softness? Ok....

Atticus chestnut ++
Capri butternut ++++
Hand antiqued saddle +
Mesquite saddle lightly burnished +
Rio whiskey +
Stampede harness +
Sonoma chestnut ++++ (careful, this is a suede and not suitable for most seating areas)
Scout clove ++
Tiburon chestnut ++
Tuscany saddle ++
Weston tobacco +++
Yardley tobacco ++

Thanks Duane! This will help with my swatch request. :)