I know this comparison has been asked before, but wanted an update.

1) Smith Brothers 820-56 & Ottoman 820-40
vs.
2) Bradington Young Marietta Swivel Glider Tub Chair


In the BY - I really hate the "puddling" idea of the cushion long term. Should I go with the Spring Down to avoid that? Does Smith also puddle over time?

Quality of leather/stitching/mechanism of Smith vs. BY?

Thanks
Karen