I was on your site and found a post from 2009 I think that mentioned about overthinking sofas – so I suspect we are not the first

WE "thought" we has settled on H&M September sofas and Document Bordeaux and then we went back and looked at the Capri Bordeaux leather and we both liked it. The concern is it is unprotected leather and I eat popcorn and we drink wine on our couches now and will continue to..

We saw a couple grade 4 “protected” leathers (Antelope Wine) and (Aspen Bordeaux) that we liked (antelope being the best due to less grain)

As far as grade 2 leathers we liked the Document Chestnut and Hanson Claret but do not know anything about them. (We dropped the Document Bordeaux as being too shiny.)

We can afford either but want to be sure we have a long term solution and do not want spend $$ unnecessarily. Do you have a recommendation?

I read your post about a leather protection product but it was not really conclusive. Do you have any update on it? Will popcorn be ok? :-)