What's a fair price? Cross Moore Recliner

[alexandratexas]

Found this H&M Cross Moore Recliner on Craigslist. Owner asking $1,400, but will take $1,000. The cushion is a little more broken in towards the back than I'd prefer, and there are small spots of spills (likely can be cleaned off). The back is in good condition - not great. This leather makes a rubber sound and it is not as buttery feeling as my new darker (dream chestnut) Ricki H&M sofa (see cushion next to it for color reference). The recliner is at least six-seven years old. I think $1,000 is way too high for the condition, although it's a beautiful chair.

1. What's your opinion - what's a fair price?
2. Do the leathers go (recliner and cushion of the Ricki sofa (dream chestnut)? Not sure if the styles will go either.