I have finally settled on what I want -- the H&M #5635 Arrington in Keenan Toffee -- I thought I would be just fine with the standard A nails...then I started looking at pictures and went down a rabbit hole!

I don't want gilt nails, that feels like too much attention, but I do want something that looks special/different... The rest of my house is decidedly not traditional -- I've got a lot of hot pinks, teals, and green in here -- but I think this piece is transitional enough to fit with a lot of different styles.

I'm still leaning toward the standard nails, but should I go out on a limb and consider BK Black nickel? Or maybe H "antique?" Or even L "natural" (that one seems a little too dull...)

I'll probably just circle back to the standard A nail and move on, I tend to get really hung up on one part for a minute and then make a decision and move on (fortunately I tend not to dwell) But if anyone has thoughts, let me know!