Which sofa set looks best with my Arts & Crafts Stickley Furniture

[erinn]

Which sofa do you like? The top collage features the H&M Leslie Sofa & Kenmore Chair. The bottom collage features the James Farm Sofa & matching chair. I live in a 1920's craftsman bungalow. I am trying to make a final decision on which H&M sofa will go best with my Stickley mission style furniture represented in the collage. A sample of my rug and the fabric that will go on my two Stickley Morris chairs are also shown. My husband likes one sofa and I like the other, but he is a smart man and is leaving the final call to me. But I'd appreciate any opinions before I make my final decision. Whatever one I do end up with will be in a tan burnished leather as seen in the bottom collage.