Which chair to buy

[96act]

I am trying to decide between the Jessica Charles Cagney Swivel/ Rocker vs. the Jessica Charles Alexander Chippendale Chair. I would get the matching ottoman for whichever one I decide on. I am looking at the Debro Cranberry fabric and the Lark Taupe fabric. I have a dark brown leather sectional and I wanted to add some fabric to the room. Any suggestions on which chair and which fabric? I can paint the walls any color.

ps I also like the Henley wall huger by Bradington-Young.

Thanks!