Hi, Helen203.
Your current three leather choices are beautiful. It appears each color will fit right in with your home, as well. Are you and your husband favoring one over the others, yet?
TXCajun
I think Hyde Park Brownie. I never thought we'd go with mid-to-dark brown, but its so nice!
I think that third one might look a little washed out against the stone. I would go with one of the brown options.
I agree about Capri Plateau in my LR. The Capri leathers are so soft, so alluring...so fragile. We are choosing Hyde Park Brownie, a little darker than we planned, but we have unusual design constraints with both brick and stone elements in the room. Hiking Boot Cognac was a pricier contender.
The fourth option is best for your room, as you can add up to two H&M pieces like couches without covering the extra space for the walkway, Hopes this help.
I agree -- we're going with two couches :-)